Fable II - Amazing Apple Pie

Obviously when I thought about making something from the Fable series my first thought was “Crunchy Chick”… then I realised that putting a chick on a plate is not a recipe and being evil is well, evil. And horns are so out this season. But across Albion there’s a lot of fresh produce including various fruits that are often baked into their more delicious form: pies. You can pick from blueberry or apple and since Autumn is swiftly and powerfully blowing it’s way in I felt a rustic and warming apple pie would be perfect. But not just any pie (especially not the rancid or crabapple kind) - it has to be Amazing Apple Pie.
Apparently this specific type of pie can only be accessed via the Pub Games pre-order bonus and playing the Spinnerbox game. I, however, did not receive my Pub Games bonus despite my pre-order all those years ago (I’m talking to YOU Amazon) so, I’m without specific reference here. It’s so special because “it fully heals you - even in the middle of combat!” and “causes you to lose weight instead of gain it”. Sounds like my kind of pie.
This recipes serves 6-8.
What you will need: A 9-inch pie dish, 2 large mixing bowls, 2 small bowls, a sieve, wooden spoon, rolling pin, cling film, a strainer, 2 large flat baking trays, a non-stick pot.
For the Pastry:
350g Plain Flour
1 Teaspoon Salt
30g Light Brown Sugar
225g Unsalted Butter
30-60ml Cold Water
Milk & 1 Small Egg (for bonding/glaze)
For the Filling:
6 Large Cooking Apples
110g Golden Caster Sugar
1 Tablespoon Fresh Lemon Juice
1 Teaspoon Ground Cinnamon
¼ Teaspoon Ground Nutmeg
Pinch of Salt
30g Unsalted Butter
1½ Tablespoons Cornflour
Apple Filling Preparations:
- Peel and slice your apples into generous chunks - place them in a bowl filled with cold water to stop them from browning as you chop. Strain from the water and return to the bowl.
- Add the sugar, salt, lemon juice, ground cinnamon and nutmeg to the apples and mix well. Let this sit for at least 30 minutes to an hour while you prepare the pastry.
Making the Pastry:
- In a large bowl sieve in the flour, salt , sugar and mix.
- Cut the butter into chunks and add them to the flour mixture. Rub the butter into the flour until it resembles crumbs.
- Add the water slowly and mix very gently until a smooth dough begins to form - you wont need it all.
- Lay some cling film on your work surface and turn the dough out onto it. Form the dough into a ball, split it in half and then wrap each portion in some cling film. Place in the fridge for an hour.
- After an hour - lay a large piece of cling film on a clean counter. Remove one of the dough portions and place it in the middle of the sheet. Lay another equally sized piece of cling film over the top and roll out the pastry (always roll pastry from the centre out) - using the cling film like this will stop the dough from sticking to anything.
- Once the desired size and an even thickness, remove the top layer of cling film. Pick up the dough using the cling film underneath and swiftly flip it over onto the pie dish - cover with cling film and return to the fridge to chill.
- Do the same with the second piece of dough, but instead, once rolled out keep it covered with the cling film and transfer it to a flat baking tray and then pop it back in the fridge - this piece will be your pie crust.
Making the Amazing Apple Pie:
- By now your apples should have stewed nicely and have some juice at the bottom. Place a strainer over a bowl and pour the apples into the strainer leaving the juices to drain for about 15 minutes.
- Once strained, pour the juices into a non-stick pot and add the 30g of butter. Allow to simmer on a medium heat for a few minutes until the liquid has slightly reduced. Do NOT allow it to boil - I accidentally made (delicious) toffee instead!
- Remove the pie crust from the fridge and allow it to sit at room temperature for about 10 minutes.
- Move the strained apples to a bowl and mix them with the cornflour.
- Take out the pie base from the fridge and fill it with the apples, leaving no gaps, making sure the apples come just above the edge of the pie dish and are level, pour over the reduced juices.
- In a small bowl beat the egg with a few tablespoons of milk. Wet the edges of the pie base with a little of the milk and egg mixture.
- Use the same technique as before and flip the pie crust over the apples. Tuck in any excess pastry under the base edges, trim anything extreme and create a nice crimping pattern if you wish with your fingers.
- With a sharp knife make five 2inch cuts from the middle of the pie outward so steam can escape.
- Cover the pie with cling film and refrigerate.
- Preheat the oven to 220C, and place a flat baking tray lined with some tinfoil on the bottom rack.
- Once heated, remove the pie from the fridge and remove the cling film, brush lightly with the milk and egg mixture and place the pie onto the baking tray and allow to cook for 45-55 minutes. Keep an eye on the pie and be sure to cover the edges of the pie with some tin foil once golden or else they will burn.
- Once cooked, leave to cool for several hours before serving warm or cool with some cream or vanilla ice-cream.

There’s a lot of steps up there - but I assure you it’s actually rather easy to make. I’ve never made pastry or pie in my life and mine turned out perfectly! Well it is a little lumpier than the picture, I think I got a bit over excited and didn’t pay attention to the amount of apples I was piling in, so I made sure to add a note about it in the recipe. I did buy some back up ready-pastry after the horror stories I’d heard about making your own, but it was so easy to do it’s almost embarrassing that people use it. Let’s just say the words “pie master” were mumbled in between the gorging. The pie dish was surprisingly expensive - as this was a success though it warrants the making of some sort of pie every week for the next 10 years to balance the cost. So get on that Spinnerbox game, because the only thing your dog is going to dig out the ground is a condom that, let’s face it, you’re never going to use.
Like this? You might also enjoy the Legend of Grimrock - Blueberry Pie.
Don’t forget you can VOTE HERE for the Gourmet Gaming Hallowe’en Special!